research-to-policy-logo

Approximately two-thirds of youth in the United States report experiencing at least one adverse childhood experience (ACE). ACEs include child maltreatment, such as abuse and neglect, as well as other experiences, such as parental incarceration and exposure to domestic violence. 

Some evidence suggests that structured extracurricular and afterschool programs (e.g., sports, arts, mentoring programs, and clubs) may help buffer negative outcomes associated with ACEs. These activities can provide safe, supervised environments; supportive adult relationships; and opportunities to build social and emotional skills, such as self-regulation and perspective-taking. These supports may promote resilience, helping youth achieve positive outcomes despite adversity. 

However, program costs, transportation challenges, and eligibility restrictions can limit participation. Youth in foster care, homeschooling, virtual schooling, or other nontraditional educational settings may face additional barriers. Policymakers could consider options to expand equitable access to high-quality activities that support academic achievement and well-being, including among youth who have experienced ACEs. 

Extracurricular Activities May Support Positive Outcomes Following Adversity 

Structured activities may support youth who have experienced adversity by strengthening connections to trusted adults, peers, and community resources. 

  • Youth involved with the child welfare system may particularly benefit from extracurricular participation. Some studies have found that even moderate involvement in structured activities was associated with improved reading and math achievement among youth with histories of maltreatment investigations. 
  • Positive extracurricular environments help youth build self-confidence, healthy coping skills, and supportive relationships. These resources may help buffer adverse outcomes associated with ACEs. 
  • Findings about improved outcomes among youth with maltreatment histories support the potential value of extracurricular participation following adversity. They do not establish that participation prevents abuse, neglect, or other ACEs, although this remains a possibility that needs to be tested. 

Extracurricular Activities Promote Healthy Youth Development 

Research on extracurricular participation more broadly suggests potential academic, social, and emotional benefits. These findings help explain how activities may support positive development, although not all studies specifically examine youth who have experienced ACEs. 

  • Some research links participation with academic achievement, school engagement, leadership skills, and emotional well-being. 

Barriers Limit Participation for Many Children and Families 

Access to extracurricular opportunities is uneven, potentially limiting participation among youth who could benefit. 

  • Youth in foster care, virtual schooling, homeschooling, or other nontraditional educational settings may face additional barriers because of eligibility rules, placement instability, or transportation limitations. 
  • Access alone does not ensure program quality. Coaches, mentors, and program leaders may lack adequate training to recognize and respond to youth mental health needs. 

Policy Options  

Expand affordable access to structured extracurricular programs 

  • States and local communities may consider reducing participation costs through scholarships, transportation assistance, or partnerships with schools and community organizations.  
    • Example legislation: Pennsylvania S.B.1441 (proposed) would establish a Youth Activity Participation Tax Credit to help families offset costs associated with their children’s participation in qualified youth activities. 
  • Expand participation opportunities for students in home education, virtual learning, and foster care. Review eligibility requirements to identify unnecessary barriers, and provide academic support alongside participation for students who need additional assistance. 

Support high-quality mentoring and youth development programs 

  • Programs that include trained adult mentors, structured supervision, and opportunities for positive peer interaction as essential components are associated with stronger developmental outcomes.  
    • Example legislation: New Jersey S.B. 4831 (proposed) would establish an independent authority and fund in NJ to invest settlement proceeds from technology company litigation into evidence-based programs that support positive youth development. 

Increase community-based opportunities in underserved areas 

  • Research suggests that neighborhood educational and recreational opportunities may support children experiencing ACEs and help address associated behavioral challenges. 
  • Communities may benefit from investments in afterschool programs, recreation centers, arts initiatives, and youth sports programs in areas with limited resources. 

The Research-to-Policy Collaboration (RPC) works to bring together research professionals and public officials to support evidence-based policy. Please visit their website to learn more.

Key Information

Publication Date
October 22, 2026

Topic Area(s)
Education and Child Development

Resource Type
Written Briefs

Share This Page

Approximately two-thirds of youth in the United States report experiencing at least one adverse childhood experience (ACE). ACEs include child maltreatment, such as abuse and neglect, as well as other experiences, such as parental incarceration and exposure to domestic violence. 

Some evidence suggests that structured extracurricular and afterschool programs (e.g., sports, arts, mentoring programs, and clubs) may help buffer negative outcomes associated with ACEs. These activities can provide safe, supervised environments; supportive adult relationships; and opportunities to build social and emotional skills, such as self-regulation and perspective-taking. These supports may promote resilience, helping youth achieve positive outcomes despite adversity. 

However, program costs, transportation challenges, and eligibility restrictions can limit participation. Youth in foster care, homeschooling, virtual schooling, or other nontraditional educational settings may face additional barriers. Policymakers could consider options to expand equitable access to high-quality activities that support academic achievement and well-being, including among youth who have experienced ACEs. 

Extracurricular Activities May Support Positive Outcomes Following Adversity 

Structured activities may support youth who have experienced adversity by strengthening connections to trusted adults, peers, and community resources. 

  • Youth involved with the child welfare system may particularly benefit from extracurricular participation. Some studies have found that even moderate involvement in structured activities was associated with improved reading and math achievement among youth with histories of maltreatment investigations. 
  • Positive extracurricular environments help youth build self-confidence, healthy coping skills, and supportive relationships. These resources may help buffer adverse outcomes associated with ACEs. 
  • Findings about improved outcomes among youth with maltreatment histories support the potential value of extracurricular participation following adversity. They do not establish that participation prevents abuse, neglect, or other ACEs, although this remains a possibility that needs to be tested. 

Extracurricular Activities Promote Healthy Youth Development 

Research on extracurricular participation more broadly suggests potential academic, social, and emotional benefits. These findings help explain how activities may support positive development, although not all studies specifically examine youth who have experienced ACEs. 

  • Some research links participation with academic achievement, school engagement, leadership skills, and emotional well-being. 

Barriers Limit Participation for Many Children and Families 

Access to extracurricular opportunities is uneven, potentially limiting participation among youth who could benefit. 

  • Youth in foster care, virtual schooling, homeschooling, or other nontraditional educational settings may face additional barriers because of eligibility rules, placement instability, or transportation limitations. 
  • Access alone does not ensure program quality. Coaches, mentors, and program leaders may lack adequate training to recognize and respond to youth mental health needs. 

Policy Options  

Expand affordable access to structured extracurricular programs 

  • States and local communities may consider reducing participation costs through scholarships, transportation assistance, or partnerships with schools and community organizations.  
    • Example legislation: Pennsylvania S.B.1441 (proposed) would establish a Youth Activity Participation Tax Credit to help families offset costs associated with their children’s participation in qualified youth activities. 
  • Expand participation opportunities for students in home education, virtual learning, and foster care. Review eligibility requirements to identify unnecessary barriers, and provide academic support alongside participation for students who need additional assistance. 

Support high-quality mentoring and youth development programs 

  • Programs that include trained adult mentors, structured supervision, and opportunities for positive peer interaction as essential components are associated with stronger developmental outcomes.  
    • Example legislation: New Jersey S.B. 4831 (proposed) would establish an independent authority and fund in NJ to invest settlement proceeds from technology company litigation into evidence-based programs that support positive youth development. 

Increase community-based opportunities in underserved areas 

  • Research suggests that neighborhood educational and recreational opportunities may support children experiencing ACEs and help address associated behavioral challenges. 
  • Communities may benefit from investments in afterschool programs, recreation centers, arts initiatives, and youth sports programs in areas with limited resources. 

The Research-to-Policy Collaboration (RPC) works to bring together research professionals and public officials to support evidence-based policy. Please visit their website to learn more.

research-to-policy-logo

Key Information

Publication Date
October 22, 2026

Topic Area(s)
Education and Child Development

Resource Type
Written Briefs

Share This Page

LET’S STAY IN TOUCH

Join the Evidence-to-Impact Mailing List

Keep up to date with the latest resources, events, and news from the EIC.